Coffee Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe (Get Ready to Impress!)

Last update:
This post contains affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.
Read our review guidelines

If you’re looking for the perfect way to impress your coffee-obsessed friends, then a homemade Italian sweet cream is the way to go!

This easy and delicious beverage can turn an ordinary cup of coffee into something much more special. From its smooth creaminess to its delicate hint of sweetness – this recipe adds a luxurious dimension you can’t get from store-bought additives.

So grab your coffee pot and read on to find out everything you need to know about making this signature coffee treat with Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream!

What is Coffee Mate Italian Sweet Cream?

This sweet cream coffee creamer is a decadent, non-dairy, triple-churned addition to any cup of coffee. This creamer is 2x richer than milk and boasts a light sweetness that will enhance the flavor of your cup of joe. Perfect for those who enjoy creamier coffee with a hint of sweetness, this creamer creates an indulgent experience you’ll love. 

And because it’s so rich and creamy, it won’t overpower the taste of your coffee – it only enhances it. Plus, thanks to its convenient liquid form, you can easily add just the right amount of flavor without measuring precise amounts like powdered creamers.

The possibilities are endless when adding Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream to your next cup of coffee – from cappuccinos and lattes to mochas and café au lait! It provides a luxurious twist on any traditional cup of java. 

So if you’re looking for a delicious way to upgrade your morning ritual, this creamer is perfect.

Ready to get started?

Read on, and you’ll find out how to make your Italian sweet cream at home!

What you’ll need for Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream

To make your own Italian sweet cream at home, you’ll need the following items:


• Medium saucepan – a medium sized saucepan is ideal for making the Italian sweet cream, as it allows you to heat the ingredients evenly and stir consistently.

• Stovetop – you’ll need a stovetop to heat your ingredients on.

• Spoon or whisk – for stirring your ingredients together, you’ll need either a spoon or whisk.

• Airtight storage container – to keep your Italian sweet cream fresh, it’s essential to store it in an airtight container for optimal flavor and texture.


• 2 cups of milk (16 ounces) – you’ll need two cups of whole milk for the recipe. You may also use low fat or skimmed varieties if desired.

• one can of sweetened condensed milk (14 ounces) – will give your Italian sweet cream its signature sweetness and creaminess.

• 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract – adds flavor complexity and depth to the Italian sweet cream.

• 1 teaspoon of almond extract – enhances the flavor profile and complements the creamy texture of the finished product.


• Begin by gathering all the necessary ingredients: 1 ½ cups of milk, ¾ cup of sweetened condensed milk, one teaspoon of vanilla extract, and ½ teaspoon of almond extract.

• Combine the milk and sweetened condensed milk in a medium saucepan.

• Heat the mixture over medium heat, stirring regularly. Continue to stir until the milk starts to steam. Do not let it boil.

• Once the milk is steaming, turn off the heat and add the vanilla and almond extracts. Stir these in until fully incorporated.

• Allow the creamer to cool completely before transferring it into an airtight container for storage. The Italian sweet cream coffee creamer can be stored in an airtight container for up to 2 weeks; however, this may vary depending on when the expiration date of your milk is reached. When ready to use, pour some creamer into your brewed coffee or tea for a delicious treat!

Recipe tips for Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream

Here are some tips for making the perfect cream:

• When making a cup of coffeemate’s Italian sweet creme coffee, be sure to measure the ingredients correctly. Use a teaspoon or tablespoon according to what is written in the recipe. Too much or too little creamer can alter the flavor of your coffee.

• Preheat your mug before adding your coffee, as this will help ensure it remains warm throughout the process. Additionally, preheating will bring out the full flavor potential of the coffee, as well as keep it enjoyable throughout consumption.

• If possible, purchase freshly roasted beans for maximum freshness and flavor extraction when brewing your coffee. Coffee that has been sitting for too long may not have enough flavor and aroma for proper enjoyment when enjoyed with Italian sweet cream coffee.

• When preparing Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream, you have many different milk types. For a classic cup of coffee, use regular or alternative milk, such as almond or coconut milk. Alternatively, if you need a richer creamer, you can use heavy cream instead of milk. Evaporated milk is an excellent option if you don’t have any fresh milk on hand. If you want to make your sweet cream even sweeter and more decadent, use canned sweetened condensed milk for an indulgent treat. No matter what kind of milk you choose, each one will give your coffee its unique flavor and texture.

• To make a fancier version of this classic beverage, add some fully melted dark chocolate chips (or any other type) for extra richness and sweetness! Sprinkle some cinnamon on top for added flavor and aroma, as well as an excellent presentation look when serving to guests and family members alike.

Different flavors of Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream

When preparing this amazing sweet cream, you can create a variety of delicious and unique flavors simply by adding extracts and spices.

Here are some variations to try:

  • Vanilla: adding vanilla extract creates a smooth, sweet flavor that enhances the creamy texture of the creamer.
  • Almond: for an added nutty flavor, almond extract is an excellent addition to the traditional Italian sweet cream.
  • Mint: if you’re looking for something cooling, the mint extract is the way to go! Try adding a few drops for freshness.
  • Hazelnut: this is your best bet if you like something with a bit more depth and richness. It creates a fantastic aroma and flavor that will take your coffee creamer creations to the next level.
  • Cinnamon: the subtle spice of cinnamon pairs perfectly with the sweetness of the creamer. Add just enough for a hint of warmth without overpowering it.
  • Cardamom: this adds an exotic and spicy kick to your coffee creamer creations, as well as helping it stand out from other options on the market!


Making the perfect cup of Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream can be tricky, but troubleshooting any issues that arise doesn’t have to be complicated. 

With just a few simple tips and tricks, you can easily ensure your coffee making experience goes as smoothly as possible!

Unpleasant flavor

If your coffee is scalded or has a slightly burnt taste, it may be because the milk was over-heated. To prevent this from happening, bring the milk to a gentle simmer instead of boiling it, and remember to keep an eye on the temperature. Also, reduce the heat slightly after it reaches a simmer to keep it from boiling. 

Additionally, keeping an eye on how long you’re cooking the milk will help ensure that it doesn’t get cooked too quickly. Finally, if you notice that your Italian sweet cream is starting to look thicker than usual, try stirring it frequently and reducing the temperature slightly – this should help prevent the milk from burning and ensure that your coffee tastes delicious!

Too Thin

To ensure your creamer is thick and creamy, use whole milk or other high fat kinds of milk such as oat and coconut. These types of milk will create a thicker creamer than skimmed milk.

Additionally, ensure the simmering process is done correctly by keeping the heat on for 5-10 minutes at an ideal temperature. This will reduce the amount of liquid in the mix and result in a richer, creamier result. If your creamer is too watery, it’s likely because you weren’t cooking it for long enough, so try to increase the time it’s simmering to eliminate excess liquid.

Furthermore, if your creamer has a grainy consistency, try increasing the amount of sugar used while stirring continuously until everything dissolves thoroughly. Finally, if you need to thicken your creamer further after this, try adding some cornstarch while stirring slowly until it reaches your desired consistency.

Wrapping Up

The Italian sweet cream recipe is a fantastic way to impress your family and friends at any event. Not only is it delicious, but it’s also easy to make with ingredients in almost any kitchen. 

For those who love coffee and cream, it’s a must-try! The combination of sweet cream and coffee enhances the flavor, and you can customize it to your choice. With a few simple steps, you can have something that looks like it came from a professional barista. So go ahead and try it out for yourself!

When looking for other coffee recipes that impress your family or friends, check our website for more recipes and ideas. You won’t be disappointed!


Is Italian creamer the same as French vanilla creamer?

No, Italian creamer and French vanilla creamer are two different flavors. The Italian sweet cream is made with sugar and cream, while the French vanilla is usually flavored with vanilla extract. Both have a unique taste and offer a delicious way to enjoy your coffee.

Does Coffee Mate Italian sweet cream contain caffeine?

No, this creamer does not contain any caffeine. It is a powdered creamer that can add flavor and creaminess to hot drinks such as coffee and tea. The product is made with real sugar and natural flavorings, providing a fuller taste without the added stimulant of caffeine. Additionally, since it does not contain any artificial flavors or colors, you can enjoy its delicate sweetness without the worry of consuming artificial additives.

How long does Italian sweet cream coffee creamer last in the fridge?

This creamer should last up to two weeks in the refrigerator when stored properly. Make sure to store it in an airtight container and consume it within this time frame for optimal freshness.

Which is better –half & half or milk?

It all depends on what you’re looking for! Half and half is a combination of milk and cream, so it’s richer than just plain milk. On the other hand, milk has less fat and calories than half & half, making it better for those watching their weight. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide which tastes best in your coffee.

What are the best dairy-free coffee creamer alternatives?

If you’re looking for a dairy-free option, consider using almond milk or other non-dairy milk, such as oat and coconut. These alternative kinds of milk create a thicker creamer than skimmed milk, so you can still enjoy the same delicious tastes without the added dairy.

Photo of author


Lorena is a writer and coffee lover who has been researching and writing about coffee for over five years. She has a passion for learning about all aspects of coffee, from how it is grown and harvested to the different brewing methods used around the world. Lorena’s goal is to share her knowledge with as many people as possible, and she does this through her writing on the Brew Coffee Daily. In addition to articles, Lorena also writes coffee reviews, offering readers an unbiased look at different brands and roasts. Whether you’re a coffee novice or a seasoned pro, Lorena’s writing will give you a new perspective on this beloved beverage.

Related posts