The 12 Best Dark Roast Coffee Beans – Redefine Your Brew

Last update:
This post contains affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.
Read our review guidelines

There’s nothing quite like that bold, rich flavor of a perfect dark roast to kickstart your morning and get you going!  

As a dedicated coffee lover and experienced product reviewer in the coffee industry, I’ve tried countless dark roast beans to find the crème de la crème. 

Choosing the right coffee beans is crucial for that perfect cup of dark roast, so I’ve put together this comprehensive guide to the best coffee beans dark roast available.

I’m thrilled to share my top pick with you today: Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee. It truly stands out for its remarkable taste, aroma, and overall quality. 

But wait, there’s more! 

To cater to coffee enthusiasts’ diverse preferences and brewing styles, I’ve also compiled a list of great dark roast beans, each with unique features and benefits. You’ll find something exceptional to suit your taste, whether you’re craving a smooth low-acidity brew, a high caffeine kick, or a rare peaberry experience. 

So, grab your favorite coffee mug, and let’s dive into the world of dark roast excellence!

A Brief Comparison of Our Favorite Brands

IMAGE
PRODUCT
DETAILS

TOP PICK

Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee

Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee

Organic
Fair Trade
Arabica

BEST ORGANIC

Don-Pablo Subtle Earth Organic Coffee Dark Roast

Don Pablo – Subtle Earth Organic Coffee

Organic
Fair Trade
Arabica

BEST SINGLE ORIGIN

Volcanica Costa Rican Dark Roast Coffee

Volcanica Costa Rican Dark Roast Coffee

Single origin
High altitude
Arabica

BEST DARK ROAST

DEATH WISH COFFEE Dark Roast

DEATH WISH COFFEE Dark Roast

High caffeine
Fair Trade
Arabica and Robusta

BEST PEABERRY

KOA COFFEE - Peaberry Dark Roast

KOA COFFEE – Peaberry Dark Roast

Single origin
Unique peaberry
Premium quality

Best Flavored

Kauai Whole Bean Coffee

Kauai Whole Bean Coffee

Single origin
Sustainable farming
Arabica

BEST BLEND

STARBUCKS DARK ROAST – CAFFE VERONA

Starbucks Dark Roast – Caffe Verona

Popular brand
Balanced flavor
Arabica

Best High Caffeine

THE BEST HIGH CAFFEINE DARK ROAST

The Best High Caffeine Dark Roast

Intense flavor
High caffeine
Arabica

Best French Roast

EIGHT O’CLOCK COFFEE FRENCH ROAST

Eight O’Clock Coffee French Roast

Affordable
Bold, rich
Arabica

SPECIAL PICK

ILLY INTENSO WHOLE BEAN COFFEE

Illy Intenso Whole Bean Coffee

Quality brand
Rich flavor
Arabica

Best Espresso

Lavazza Crema E Gusto

Lavazza Crema E Gusto

Quality brand
Rich flavor
Arabica

BUDGET PICK

SEATTLE’S BEST COFFEE NO. 5

Seattle’s Best Coffee No. 5

Affordable
Smooth flavor
Arabica

Keep reading to learn about the best dark roast coffee beans and determine which suits your preferences.

The 12 Best Dark Roasted Coffee Beans Brands

BEST OVERALL
Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Rich, smooth
Beans Type: 100% Arabica

Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee is a 100% Arabica, organic dark roast with a smooth flavor profile and low acidity, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a gentler taste. This coffee hails from Latin America and is crafted by Mayorga Organics, a company dedicated to socially responsible practices.

Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee is available on Amazon and boasts the USDA Organic certification, ensuring that it is produced in an environmentally friendly and sustainable manner. During my experience with this coffee, I found the taste exceptionally smooth, with a slight hint of chocolate and caramel notes. The beans were evenly roasted, and the aroma was pleasantly inviting.

This versatile coffee works well with various brewing methods such as French press, pour-over, and drip coffee machines. However, it may not be ideal for people who love a bold, strong coffee, as its intensity is milder than other dark roasts.

Nonetheless, its smooth flavor and low acidity make it an excellent option for those who want to indulge in a dark roast without overwhelming their taste buds.

BEST ORGANIC
Don-Pablo Subtle Earth Organic Coffee Dark Roast
Product details:

Origin: Honduras
Taste: Chocolatey, caramel, honey
Beans Type: 100% Arabica

Don Pablo’s Subtle Earth Organic Coffee is a dark roast whole bean coffee made from 100% Arabica beans, offering a rich and balanced flavor that coffee lovers will appreciate.

Sourced from high-altitude regions in Honduras, this coffee is characterized by its low acidity and GMO-free certification, contributing to its clean and natural taste.

This coffee is readily available on Amazon and holds the USDA Organic and GMO-Free certifications, ensuring it meets strict quality standards. While testing Don Pablo’s Subtle Earth Organic Coffee, I was impressed by the harmony between its boldness and mild fruity undertones. The aroma was captivating and filled my kitchen with a delightful scent.

Don Pablo’s Subtle Earth Organic Coffee is well-suited for various brewing methods such as espresso, pour-over, and cold brew. Some users may occasionally find the bean quality inconsistent, but overall, it delivers a gratifying coffee experience.

In addition, its balanced taste makes it an excellent choice for those seeking an organic dark roast that doesn’t compromise on flavor or quality.

BEST SINGLE ORIGIN
Volcanica Costa Rican Dark Roast Coffee
Product details:

Origin: Costa Rica
Taste: Chocolatey, fruity
Beans Type: 100% Arabica

Volcanica Costa Rican Dark Roast Coffee is a 100% Arabica, dark roast coffee with a unique flavor profile that sets it apart.

Sourced from high-altitude regions in Costa Rica, this coffee is Rainforest Alliance Certified, ensuring it is grown and harvested sustainably and responsibly.

You can find Volcanica Costa Rican Dark Roast Coffee on the Volcanica Coffee website. My personal experience with this coffee was nothing short of remarkable.

The beans were uniformly roasted, and the aroma was captivatingly fruity and floral. The taste was distinct, with hints of chocolate and citrus, offering a delightful blend of flavors that lingered on the palate.

This coffee works exceptionally well with brewing methods such as pour-over, drip coffee machines, and espresso. It may not be the best choice for those who prefer milder coffee, as its robust flavors cater to the more adventurous coffee drinkers.

However, its limited availability and slightly higher price point make it a special treat for those seeking a unique Costa Rican coffee experience.

BEST DARK ROAST
DEATH WISH COFFEE Dark Roast
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Bold, strong
Beans Type: Arabica and Robusta

DEATH WISH COFFEE Whole Bean Coffee Dark Roast is designed for those who crave an intense caffeine kick.

This dark roast coffee is made from a blend of Arabica and Robusta beans, producing a high-caffeine content and a smooth, robust taste. It also boasts the USDA Organic certification, ensuring the coffee is produced using environmentally friendly practices.

Available on Amazon, DEATH WISH COFFEE Dark Roast certainly lives up to its name. I found the beans well-roasted and the aroma bold and powerful during my testing. The flavor was strong but smooth, with a pleasant balance of bitter and sweet notes. This coffee is not for the faint-hearted or those sensitive to caffeine.

DEATH WISH COFFEE Dark Roast suits various brewing methods, including French press, espresso, and drip coffee machines. Due to its high caffeine content may not be the best option for those who prefer a milder coffee or are sensitive to caffeine.

However, if you’re seeking an energetic boost from your morning brew, DEATH WISH COFFEE will surely deliver.

BEST PEABERRY
KOA COFFEE - Peaberry Dark Roast
Product details:

Origin: Hawaii
Taste: Smooth, full-bodied
Beans Type: Arabica

KOA COFFEE’s Peaberry Dark Roast Whole Bean 100% Kona Coffee offers a rare and luxurious coffee experience featuring exclusive Peaberry beans.

These beans, which make up only about 5% of the total Kona coffee harvest, are known for their smooth taste and high quality. In addition, the dark roast enhances the natural flavors of the Kona beans, resulting in a truly exceptional coffee.

Available on the KOA Coffee website, this Peaberry Dark Roast Kona Coffee is a genuine treat for coffee connoisseurs.

My personal experience with this coffee was delightful – the beans were evenly roasted, and the aroma was rich and inviting. The taste was smooth with hints of chocolate and a touch of fruity sweetness, creating a well-rounded flavor profile that left a lasting impression.

This coffee works well with various brewing methods, including pour-over, espresso, and French press. While it may not satisfy those who prefer a bold, strong coffee, the rare Peaberry beans offer a unique and indulgent experience for true coffee enthusiasts.

In addition, its higher price point and limited availability make it a special treat for those seeking a one-of-a-kind coffee experience.

BEST FLAVORED
Kauai Whole Bean Coffee
Product details:

Origin: Hawaii
Taste: Smooth, rich
Beans Type: Arabica

Kauai Whole Bean Coffee, is a 100% Arabica Hawaiian coffee that brings a unique and exotic flavor to your daily brew.

Sourced from the Koloa Estate in Hawaii, this dark roast coffee is grown sustainably, ensuring an environmentally friendly and responsible production process.

You can find Kauai Whole Bean Coffee on Amazon, offering a taste of Hawaii in every cup. My experience with this coffee was enjoyable – the beans were well-roasted, and the aroma had a distinct and enticing tropical scent. In addition, the flavor was unique, with a touch of nuttiness and hints of dark chocolate, making it a memorable coffee experience.

Koloa Estate Dark Roast suits various brewing methods, such as drip coffee machines, pour-over, and French press. However, some users may find the roast inconsistent or the aroma weak. Still, its affordable price and unique Hawaiian flavor make it an appealing option for those seeking something different from their daily brew.

In addition, its distinctive taste caters to coffee lovers who appreciate an exotic twist to their dark roast coffee.

BEST BLEND
Starbucks Dark Roast - Caffe Verona
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Rich, bold
Beans Type: Arabica

Starbucks Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee — Caffe Verona is a well-known and popular option for dark roast coffee lovers.

This whole bean coffee features a rich and bold flavor profile that Starbucks fans will recognize and appreciate. In addition, its wide availability, consistent taste, and the reputation of the Starbucks brand make it a reliable choice for your daily dark roast fix.

You can find Caffe Verona at Amazon, Starbucks stores, and other retailers. The beans were evenly roasted during my testing, and the aroma was intense and enticing.

The taste was rich, with dark chocolate notes and a hint of caramel sweetness, balanced by a slight bitterness. The coffee had a strong aftertaste, which may only suit some’s preferences.

Caffe Verona is suitable for various brewing methods, including espresso, drip coffee machines, and pour-over.

Although the coffee can be bitter and slightly expensive, its consistent flavor and wide availability make it a popular choice for those seeking a reliable and familiar dark roast coffee.

BEST HIGH CAFFEINE
The Best High Caffeine Dark Roast
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Strong, bold
Beans Type: Arabica

The Best High Caffeine Dark Roast is designed for coffee enthusiasts looking for a strong flavor and an energizing caffeine boost.

This dark roast coffee is crafted from a blend of beans with a high caffeine content and a smooth, robust taste that will appeal to those who prefer a bolder coffee experience.

You can find this high-caffeine coffee on Amazon. My personal experience with this coffee was quite refreshing – the beans were well-roasted, and the aroma was powerful and enticing.

The flavor was strong and rich, with a pleasant balance of bitter and sweet notes. This coffee is definitely not for caffeine-sensitive individuals or those who prefer milder coffee.

The Best High Caffeine Dark Roast is suitable for various brewing methods, including French press, espresso, and drip coffee machines. Its high caffeine content and robust flavor make it an excellent choice for those seeking an energizing boost from their daily coffee.

However, the slightly higher price point and inconsistent quality may deter some consumers.

BEST FRENCH ROAST
Eight O'Clock Coffee French Roast
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Bold, rich
Beans Type: Arabica

Eight O’Clock Coffee French Roast is a budget-friendly dark roast coffee that offers a rich and full-bodied flavor for those seeking a more affordable option.

In addition, this whole bean coffee boasts a French roast profile, giving it a distinct and robust taste that appeals to many coffee drinkers.

You can find Eight O’Clock Coffee French Roast on Amazon and other retailers. In my personal testing, the beans were mostly evenly roasted, and the aroma was pleasant, with a hint of smokiness. The taste was rich and bold, with a slight bitterness that some may find appealing. However, the roast and aroma could be inconsistent at times.

This coffee is suitable for various brewing methods, including drip coffee machines, pour-over, and French press. Despite its roast inconsistencies and potential for bitterness, it’s affordability and rich flavor make it a good option for those seeking a budget dark roast coffee.

SPECIAL PICK
illy Intenso Whole Bean Coffee
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Rich, full-bodied
Beans Type: Arabica

illy Intenso Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, is an Italian coffee brand known for its consistent taste and smooth flavor.

This dark roast coffee offers a well-rounded taste profile that appeals to those who appreciate the quality of Italian coffee without the need for an overwhelmingly strong brew.

You can find illy Intenso Whole Bean Coffee at Amazon and other retailers. My personal experience with this coffee was enjoyable – the beans were well-roasted, and the aroma was rich and inviting.

The taste was smooth, with a nice balance of bitterness and sweetness, making it a satisfying cup of coffee. However, some might find it weaker than other dark roasts.

illy Intenso is suitable for various brewing methods, including espresso, pour-over, and drip coffee machines. Although it can be pricier and may not be strong enough for some, its consistent taste, smooth flavor, and Italian coffee heritage make it an excellent choice for those seeking a refined coffee experience.

BEST ESPRESSO
Lavazza Crema E Gusto Whole Bean Coffee
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Creamy, chocolatey
Beans Type: Arabica and Robusta

Lavazza Crema E Gusto is an affordable Italian coffee option, delivering a smooth flavor and a balanced taste profile. This dark roast coffee offers a satisfying brew for those who enjoy Italian coffee without breaking the bank.

Lavazza Crema E Gusto is available on Amazon and other retailers. During my personal testing, the whole beans were mostly evenly roasted, and the aroma was pleasant. The taste was smooth, with a balance of bitter and sweet notes. However, some might find the aroma weak or the coffee not strong enough.

This coffee is suitable for various brewing methods, including espresso, drip coffee machines, and pour-over. Despite its inconsistent bean quality and potential for a weak aroma, it’s affordability and smooth flavor make it a popular choice for those seeking a budget Italian coffee experience.

BUDGET PICK
Seattle's Best Coffee Signature Blend No. 5
Product details:

Origin: Blend
Taste: Bold, roasty
Beans Type: Arabica

Seattle’s Best Coffee No. 5 is an affordable dark roast coffee that delivers a rich flavor and a satisfying cup of coffee. This whole bean coffee features a signature blend of beans, creating a unique taste profile that appeals to many dark roast coffee lovers.

You can find Seattle’s Best Coffee No. 5 on Amazon and other retailers. In my personal experience, the beans were mostly evenly roasted, and the aroma was inviting with a touch of smokiness. The taste was rich and full-bodied, with a hint of bitterness. However, the tasting notes of the roast and aroma could be inconsistent at times.

This coffee suits various brewing methods, including drip coffee machines, pour-over, and French press. Despite its roast inconsistencies and potential for a weak aroma, its affordability and rich

Buying Guide for the Best Coffee Beans Dark Roast

When shopping for dark roast coffee beans, it’s essential to consider factors such as region of origin, bean variety and grade, and roasting process. Besides these points, you may also want to look into the sustainability of the beans. 

Here is a brief guide on how you can pick out the best dark roast beans:

1. Flavor Profile and Roast Level

Understanding your coffee beans’ flavor profile and roast level is essential for selecting the perfect dark roast blend that caters to your preferences. Different roasts offer unique taste experiences, and it’s crucial to find the one that matches your taste buds.

  • Look for flavor notes that appeal to you, such as chocolate, caramel, or fruity undertones, to enhance your coffee experience.
  • Ensure the roast level is dark enough to suit your taste buds but not overly bitter or burnt, which may affect the overall enjoyment of your cup.

2. Origin and Quality of Beans

The origin and quality of beans play a crucial role in determining your coffee’s overall taste and experience. Different regions produce beans with distinct characteristics, so it’s vital to consider this aspect when selecting your dark roast coffee beans.

  • Look for single-origin beans or blends that come from reputable coffee-growing regions, as they often provide unique and high-quality flavors.
  • Opt for high-quality beans, such as 100% Arabica, to ensure a more refined and balanced flavor in your brewed coffee.

3. Organic, Fair Trade, and Sustainability

Being mindful of coffee production’s environmental and social impacts is essential for responsible coffee consumption. Choosing ethically sourced and sustainable beans is a step towards conscious coffee drinking and supporting a better future.

  • Look for certifications such as USDA Organic, Fair Trade, or Rainforest Alliance to ensure ethical practices and environmentally friendly production methods.
  • Opt for coffee brands that prioritize sustainability and support local coffee farmers, contributing to the communities well-being.

4. Freshness and Packaging

Freshness is a critical factor in your coffee’s overall quality and taste. Proper packaging ensures that your dark roast coffee beans maintain their flavor and aroma until you’re ready to brew, providing you with a delightful coffee experience.

  • Look for brands that roast their beans in small batches to guarantee freshness, as this can significantly affect the taste and aroma of your coffee.
  • Opt for packaging with a one-way valve to allow carbon dioxide to escape while preventing oxygen from entering, maintaining the beans’ freshness.

5. Price and Availability

Finding a balance between quality and affordability is essential when purchasing coffee beans. Also, consider how easily accessible the dark roasted coffee beans are when it’s time to replenish your stock, ensuring a consistent supply of your favorite dark roast coffees.

  • Compare prices and quality across various brands to find the best value for your money without compromising taste and experience.
  • Choose coffee beans available through online retailers or local stores to ensure a consistent supply, allowing you to enjoy your favorite dark roast coffee without interruptions.

6. Brewing Method Compatibility

Different coffee beans may be more suited to specific brewing methods. Considering your preferred brewing technique will help you choose beans that cater to your taste and brewing style, ensuring the best possible coffee experience.

  • Look for dark roast beans that are compatible with your favorite brewing methods, such as espresso, pour-over, or French press, as they may offer different flavor profiles depending on the brewing technique.
  • Experiment with different beans and brewing methods to discover the perfect combination for your taste preferences, expanding your coffee horizons and finding your ideal dark roast coffee.

By taking these factors into account, you can make an informed decision when selecting the best dark roast coffee beans, catering to your taste buds and brewing preferences while being mindful of ethical and sustainable practices.

With the right beans and knowledge, you’re one step closer to enjoying the perfect cup of dark roast coffee.

The Verdict

Our roundup review of the best dark roast coffee beans showcases a diverse selection of top-quality products, each catering to specific preferences and brewing styles.

While all the products listed are excellent choices for dark roast coffee enthusiasts, our top pick, Mayorga Dark Roast Coffee, stands out as the best option. Its smooth flavor, low acidity, and socially responsible sourcing make it a versatile choice that will please most coffee lovers.

Each of the other products on our list excels in various aspects, such as unique flavors, high caffeine content, or exceptional bean quality, ensuring there’s something for everyone. So whether you’re looking for a high-caffeine kick, a rare peaberry experience, or a budget-friendly option, our list has got you covered.

Don’t wait any longer to experience the rich, bold flavors of the best dark roast coffee beans. Instead, click on the provided links to purchase your favorite product and enjoy a perfectly brewed cup of dark roast coffee today!

FAQ

What are the characteristics of an excellent dark roast coffee?

A good dark roast coffee typically has a bold, robust flavor with low acidity and a smooth finish. The beans should be roasted to a dark brown color, and the flavor profile may include notes of chocolate, caramel, or smoky undertones. Look for high-quality beans, such as 100% Arabica, to ensure a more refined taste.

How do I store dark roast coffee beans to maintain freshness?

To maintain the freshness of dark roast coffee beans, store them in an airtight container away from direct sunlight, heat, and moisture. Ideally, use a container with a one-way valve to allow carbon dioxide to escape while preventing oxygen from entering. This helps preserve the beans’ flavor and aroma for extended periods.

Can I use dark roast coffee beans with my preferred brewing method?

Dark roast coffee beans can be used with various brewing methods, such as espresso, pour-over, or French press. However, the flavor profile and extraction may differ depending on the brewing technique. Experiment with different beans and methods to find the perfect combination for your taste preferences.

What certifications should I look for when buying dark roast coffee beans?

When buying dark roast coffee beans, look for certifications like USDA Organic, Fair Trade, or Rainforest Alliance. These certifications ensure ethical practices, environmentally friendly production methods, and support for local coffee farmers. Choosing beans with these certifications contributes to responsible coffee consumption and a better future for the industry.

Photo of author

AUTHOR

Luca Dupres is the founder of Brew Coffee Daily, a website devoted to helping coffee enthusiasts make better decisions about buying and brewing quality coffee. Luca has been a coffee lover since 2014 and is passionate about food, traveling, and writing. He founded Brew Coffee Daily in 2022 with the mission of helping people make better decisions about coffee and providing them with resources and advice about all things coffee. Luca firmly believes that anyone can make great coffee with the right tools and guidance.

Related posts